Dolphin S50 Pool Cleaner VS Dolphin Active 10 Pool Cleaner

Check mark Highs
User Friendly
Energy Efficient
Large Filtration Basket
Lightweight
CleverClean Drive System
X icon Lows
Cleans Floors Only
No Anti-Tangle Swivel
Ultra-Fine Filter not Included
One Cycle Time
Few Operating Features
Coverage Very Good Good
Filtration Excellent Very Good
Cleaning Very Good Good
Intelligence Very Good Fair
Usability Excellent Excellent
Maintenance Excellent Excellent
Value Excellent Very Good
Check mark Highs
Plug-and-Play Design
Energy Efficient
Active Scrubbing Brush
Powerful Vacuum
High-Capacity FIlter
X icon Lows
Cleans Floors Only
No Anti-Tangle Swivel
No Weekly Timer
Only One Cleaning Cycle
Coverage Very Good Good
Filtration Excellent Very Good
Cleaning Very Good Good
Intelligence Very Good Fair
Usability Excellent Excellent
Maintenance Excellent Excellent
Value Very Good Good

Head To Head Review Analysis

It may not have all of the bells and whistles of other robotic pool cleaners on the market, but it isn’t hindered at all by its simplicity. For less than $500, you’ll have a hard time finding a comparable robot that can tackle an above ground pool as thoroughly as the S50 does. Its power and simplicity are the perfect combination, making it a solid choice for any small to medium-sized above ground pool.


Sure, it doesn’t have the fancy features or bells and whistles of the more expensive bots in the Active Series, but it does what it’s designed to do extremely well. It accommodates a low-maintenance pool lifestyle with its simple and seamless user experience, and its solid and sturdy design effectively cleans above and beyond other robotic pool cleaners sold at the same price. Plus, its energy efficiency is a huge perk to offset those rising electric bills in the summer months.


Dolphin S50 Pool Cleaner

Dolphin Active 10 Pool Cleaner

Customer Reviews

4.4 stars 4.4 Based on 20 Reviews
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars
How would you rate Dolphin S50 Pool Cleaner?*
Rating Stars
4.3 stars 4.3 Based on 15 Reviews
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars
How would you rate Dolphin Active 10 Pool Cleaner?*
Rating Stars
Rating Stars
5 stars

Jim -

Great pool robot! It does everything I expected and more. Great value too!

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Sue -

I wish I would have gotten my robot years ago. Saved me so much time cleaning the pool, it’s paid for itself already.

Rating Stars
Happy for $450

Dale -

This robot cleans entire bottom of our 15×24 pool & goes around the ladder. Living in Florida we wanted something that picks up all the sand from everyone’s feet & the smaller leaf’s. Easy cleaning basket pops out the top & it will come apart for spraying off with the hose. After 2 months we are happy so far!

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Donna Stiff  -

Product was great while it worked. I’ve been trying to contact the company for 1 week, leaving phone messages and email messages. Still yet to have been contacted. My product is still under warranty. My pool is in desperate need of a vacuum cleaner that works!

Rating Stars
WONDERFUL

FRAN JIAMPETTI  -

MY HUSBAND LOVES IT’S PERFORMANCE.

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Robbin  -

This dolphin cleans the pool great. We have to haul our water and cant always backwash the pool. This cleans it wonderful. It is a lifesaver

Rating Stars
Awesome

Jose Arce -

It’s great cleans my pool in about 1 hour and z30 minutes my pool is 16 by 52

Rating Stars
Best automatic cleaner I've ever used

John -

This cleaner is the only one I’ve ever owned that will actually vacuum the entire bottom of my pool. Even around the edges . It definitely gives you the same results as a hand vacume. It’s expensive but totally worth it in the long run.

Rating Stars
Love it

Susan -

This works great. Powerful suction. Easy to use. Very satisfied on how it cleans my pool

Rating Stars
Dolpfin S50

Sally Wiley -

I love it easy to use cleans very time no problems so far .

Rating Stars
Strong and powerfull

Bilal -

It has a very nice design, not like others where they are glued together and the glue come off. It also has good suction and picks up a lot of dirt. I wish it comes with the Very fine basket.

Rating Stars
I love it!!!

Jean Tucker -

I love my vacuum! My pool is under some trees and the vacuum picks up everything… it is soooo much easier than using my pool vacuum that uses the pool filter. With the dolphin’s self contained collection bag, which holds quite a bit, my sand filter does not need to be cleaned as soon often. And I think the dolphin cleans better. One enhancement, my husband wants a joy stick to tell the dolphin where to go….

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Joe  -

Works extremely well on above ground pools. I would definitely recommend this product. Only one downfall cord tangles easily.

Rating Stars
Perfect Bottom cleaner

William -

Works great, really pulls all the heavy debris up such as leaves and dirt. Will also climb part way up the wall! Easy to clean out debris that has been picked up. For the price it is worth every penny.

Rating Stars
Clean pool, No work

Harry Cottrill -

We tired of the crappy “lady bug” pool vac that came with our pool and ran off the pool pump. Decided to go with the Maytronics self powered pool vac. We’ve had this vac for a year now. Simply plug it into a 120 outlet and it’s converted into safe low voltage power which doesn’t rely or bog down your pools pump. This vac has its own rubish collect filter bag. We just set it in and forget it !!! So far, so good. Highly recommended

Rating Stars
Pool vacuum

Flora Thornton -

I love my vacuum it works great this will be my 2nd year having it

Rating Stars
Clean pool with no effort!!

Jon Varnes -

So easy and so nice to just be able to throw the dolphin in the pool and let it go!! The best way to clean the pool with no effort but plugging it in. It’s so nice to just being able to throw it in and go do something else till it’s done. Also so easy to clean, just spray out the basket and it’s ready to go for the next time

Rating Stars
Not right the first time.

Larry Rosencrans -

I purchased the Dolphin S 50 to save me the physical time to clean my pool. It will pick up most items in the pool but will not collect the finer particles. The pool looks great until an hour or two later and the particles have settled back on the bottom of the pool. I then have to manually vacuum the pool. I talked to the business I bought it from and they told me I could purchase an ultra fine filter for $100.00 that “might” pick up the fine particles. I did not know this when I spent $500.00 on the S-50 so I would not have to manually vacuum. They have basically said too bad. I can not afford to buy the ultra filter not knowing if it will solve the problem knowing they will not back up the sale with a refund if it does not.I know this because when I was looking at purchasing the S-50 I was told Is a great performer, no complaints, if your not satisfied bring it back”. I did and was told I could not return it once it had been in the water. How was I going to know how it worked if I did not put it in the water? Now they want to sell me a better filter basket. You should sell it with the ultra fine basket to begin with. I feel I have wasted my $500.00. This robot pool cleaner does not do the job Right The First Time,or the second, or the 3rd. Very disapointed.

Rating Stars
Does not clean bottom

Donna  -

I have tried reaching out to customer support with no answers I must be doing something wrong it picks up the leaves but blows them back out the top in smaller pieces if anyone has any suggestions if I am doing something wrong please let me know I am looking to replace

Rating Stars
JUNK

Jeremy Koepsell -

If you are looking for double the work then this is the cleaner for you!! Simply put it in your pool and let it run a cycle or two and just watch it break all the debris into smaller partials making it settle to the bottom of the pool again. Then remove the robot from the pool and start to hand vacuum the big mess that the robot made all in all its double the work.

Rating Stars
This is awesome!! Really cleans the pool

Simone Leite -

This is awesome !! Really cleans the pool !

Rating Stars
Five Stars

angelika wyckoff -

it really delievers

Rating Stars
Five Stars

Linnea K. Palmer -

Love it

Rating Stars
Who knew pool cleaning could be so easy?

Noel -

This thing is amazing. No more manually vacuuming the pool. I love it. This little guy does wonderful work in the pool.

Rating Stars
Poolette

Teresa Moran -

Love, love, love it! Just place in the pool and plug it in. When it’s done unplug and lift out. No wear and tear on the filter. Leaves are collected in a cartridge, couldn’t be easier! I’m now spoiled on these little robots!

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Sharon Speiser -

Excellent product. Takes the work out of cleaning the pool.

Rating Stars
Unbelievable Cleaning Ability

Jim Berry -

I can’t believe the debris that was collected in the first 1.5 hours with this device. Then i cleaned the basket and put it to work again. Once again, more debris. I couldn’t see the debris standing on the edge of the deck looking into the pool, but it was there obviously. I give this Active 10 a 5 star because of this and the fact that it is so easy to use. Open box, follow directions, and presto…clean pool!

Rating Stars
I wished I had purchased this when I bought my pool

Brad -

It’s fast: Clean pool in 1.5 hours, way faster than running the pool vacuum all night. It’s quiet: It runs on a low-voltage motor, not powered by a suction line hooked up to your pump that has to run on high speed. Cheaper to operate: Again, low-voltage motor, versus running a 12 AMP pool pump motor. Efficient: The Active 10 moves by using a dual belt track (like a tank). It learns the size of your pool; and moves in a patter that gets your pool clean in it’s 1.5 hour cycle. If you pool is re

ally dirty (beginning of season or after a storm. Pull it out then you just pull it up and clean the filter basket, put it back in, and repeat the cycle at the push of a single button. Compact: I can grab the handle with one hand, and the 30 foot of line (about the diameter of common electrical extension cord), and carry it from my garage to the pool. Much easier than dragging a heave vacuum “Shark” and 4? of 2? hose line (which will get you soaked when you put it away. More Sanitary: The debris is sucked up and stored in the easy-to-remove/clean filter basket, not sucked into my sand filter which I will now have to back flush. Saves Chemicals: I have to back-flush a lot less often, which means I’m not losing salt (for my salt water generator), and I’m not having to add fresh fill water, which will require me to have to adjust pH and alkalinity. Just more enjoyable: Because of all the things above, and my water stays cleaner and in balance with less effort, now I get to enjoy my pool instead of having to always mess with my pool. Bottom line: It cost a couple of hundred dollars more than the traditional pool vacuum and hose, but it’s worth every penny and will save you hours and hours of hassles, and will pay for itself in savings on electricity and lost chemicals. Had I someone given me this testimonial before I bought my pool, I would have done this from the start. If you are like me and did the traditional set up, oh well, UPGRADE NOW…you’ll be thanking me as BEST ADVICE EVER

Rating Stars
Powerful

David Ferguson -

This has been the best labor reducer I’ve owned. It cleans the bottom fantastically and even picks up acorns in the early fall before the pool is shut down for the winter

Rating Stars
5 Stars

Chris Ross -

very good product. saves me time by doing it by hand. little expensive but worth it. plug it in put in pool and go about rest of day. love it

Rating Stars
Love this Pool Cleaner!

Michael S  -

Unit does a great job of cleaning pool floor! Just place on pool and turn on and walk away! In a hour or 2 pool is clean.

Rating Stars
EXCEPTIONAL Love it

RuthAnn Halvorson  -

The Dolphin Active 10 is exceptional. It does far better than I ever expected. Plug it in, turn it on and watch it go! It does a great job.

Rating Stars
Although it is convenient and easy to empty the basket

Nancy S -

Although it is convenient and easy to empty the basket, I thought it would do a much better job picking up dirt. I find it just brushes the dirt off the bottom but doesn't actually pick it up. I does do a great job picking up leaves. I have to vaccum the pool each morning because of dirt on the bottom of the pool and never had to with my old Pool Rover Jr. I do like it but thought that for the amount of money I spent on it I thought my pool would be spotless after each vaccum.

Rating Stars
Poor purchase

Jeanna Yono -

I loved this product but it only last one season. After looking at reviews there are MANY who complain of the same problem. It will only go a few inches then stops! Have tried everything they told me to do and still no luck. Totally not worth the $400 dollars!

Rating Stars
Only worked for 2 seasons

Joyce A. Darrigo -

Garbage. Bought end of season in 2015. Used in 2016 and 2017 in PA which each pool season is about 4 months. So I paid $600 for a pool sweeper that lasted 8 months. Maytronics says send it back (we have to pay to return) they will fix at our cost and ship back. Really 8 months. I am so upset as we use our pool as my husband has Parkinson’s and the pool helps his legs. I cannot believe Maytronics will not stand behind their product